Stolen Vehicles, Accidents, and Insurance Coverage in Florida
Jonathan Perazzo, Miami car accident lawyer and founder of the Perazzo Law Firm, understands how overwhelming it can be when a vehicle is stolen, especially if it is later involved in a crash that causes injuries or property damage. Florida drivers frequently ask who is responsible, what insurance applies, and what happens if coverage is limited or nonexistent.
The answers depend heavily on the type of insurance carried, how the vehicle was stolen, and whether the owner acted negligently.
What Happens If Your Stolen Vehicle Is Involved in an Accident?
If your car is stolen and later crashes into another vehicle, object, or pedestrian, the owner of the stolen vehicle is generally not held legally liable for injuries or damages caused by the thief. Vehicle theft is a criminal offense, and the individual who stole the car may face criminal charges and civil liability for any harm caused.
However, even though you may not be at fault, it is still important to promptly report the theft to law enforcement and notify your insurance provider. Failure to do so can complicate or jeopardize coverage.
Insurance companies will also examine how the vehicle was stolen. For example, issues may arise if the insurer believes negligence contributed to the theft, such as leaving keys in the ignition or leaving the car running and unattended.
Who Pays for Damage to Your Stolen Vehicle?
In Florida, all registered drivers must carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PD) coverage. However, neither PIP nor PD pays for damage to your own vehicle if it is stolen or crashed.
Coverage for a stolen and damaged vehicle typically depends on whether you carry:
- Comprehensive insurance
- GAP (Guaranteed Auto Protection) insurance
Without these coverages, recovery for vehicle damage becomes extremely limited.
What Insurance Covers a Stolen and Crashed Vehicle?
Comprehensive Insurance
This coverage generally pays for damage or total loss caused by theft, vandalism, or other non-collision events. If your stolen car is recovered damaged or totaled, comprehensive coverage is usually what applies.
GAP Insurance
GAP insurance covers the difference between your vehicle’s actual cash value and the remaining loan or lease balance. This is especially important for newer vehicles that depreciate quickly. GAP does not replace comprehensive insurance, it works alongside it.
What If Your Car Is Stolen and You Have NO Insurance?
If your vehicle is stolen and you do not have comprehensive coverage—or no insurance at all—the consequences can be severe:
- You will not receive compensation for your stolen or damaged vehicle
- You remain responsible for any outstanding loan or lease balance
- There is no insurance policy to pay for repairs or replacement
- Recovery is typically limited to pursuing the thief directly, which is often impractical or impossible
While you are still generally not liable for injuries or damages caused by the thief, the financial loss of your vehicle will likely fall entirely on you. This is why comprehensive coverage is strongly recommended for Florida drivers, especially in high-theft areas like Miami.
Key Takeaway
If your vehicle is stolen and involved in an accident, you are usually not legally responsible for the damages caused, but your insurance coverage determines whether you recover anything for your own losses. Without comprehensive insurance, stolen vehicle owners often have no financial protection at all.
For guidance on stolen vehicle accidents, insurance disputes, or denied claims, contact Jonathan Perazzo, Miami car accident lawyer, at the Perazzo Law Firm.
CALL 888-PERAZZO
Contact us ONLINE for a FREE consultation
ZERO out-of-pocket fees